beehiiv vs Substack vs Kit (2026): Which to Pick?
beehiiv vs Substack vs Kit compared by creator type: fees and take rates from each official page, list export, discovery networks and ways to earn.
Key Takeaways
- Substack is free to start and keeps 10% of paid subscription revenue, with card processing fees on top, per its own pages.
- beehiiv says it takes 0% of paid subscription revenue, but charging readers needs Lite, from $49 a month billed annually.
- Kit lists 3.5% plus $0.30 per USD sale on every plan, and its free plan covers up to 10,000 subscribers.
- All three let you export your subscriber list, so the choice is reversible, though moving still costs time and some readers.
- Pick by creator type: free growth, paid subscriptions, selling products, or moving an existing audience, then check the live pricing page.
Quick answer: Pick Substack if you want to start free and grow through its reader network, beehiiv if you want 0% take on paid subscriptions and an ad network, and Kit if you sell products and need automations. Fees differ a lot, so match the platform to how you will earn before you compare features.
Last verified: November 20, 2026. Every price, fee and plan fact below comes from the platform's own page, fetched on that date and named in the text. Pricing changes often, so open the linked page before you decide.
The two-way comparisons already exist on this site. If you only care about two platforms, read Substack vs beehiiv or Substack vs ConvertKit. This guide is for people still choosing between all three, and it sorts the decision by the kind of creator you are rather than by feature count.
What is the difference between beehiiv, Substack and Kit?
The difference is what each platform assumes you are building. Substack assumes a writer with readers, beehiiv assumes a newsletter business, and Kit assumes a creator who sells things through email.
- Substack describes itself on its about page as "free to start and free to leave." It earns a share of paid subscriptions.
- beehiiv sells monthly plans by list size on its pricing page and says it takes 0% of paid subscription revenue.
- Kit calls itself "the email platform for creator business owners" on its homepage, which also notes it was formerly ConvertKit. It charges by plan and list size, plus a fee per sale.
For the wider field, including Ghost and Mailchimp, see our newsletter platforms compared roundup.
How much do beehiiv, Substack and Kit cost?
Each charges in a different way: Substack takes a revenue share, beehiiv charges a plan fee, and Kit charges a plan fee plus a per-sale fee. All figures below are as of November 20, 2026.
| Substack | beehiiv | Kit | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Free to start | Yes. "Substack is free to use," per its features page | Free plan up to 2,500 subscribers, "no credit card required" | Free plan up to 10,000 subscribers |
| Entry paid plan | No monthly plan fee | Lite: $49/mo billed annually or $59 billed monthly (up to 1,000 subscribers) | Creator: $39/mo billed monthly (1,000 subscribers) |
| Next plan | None listed | Pro: $95/mo billed annually or $109 monthly (up to 1,000 subscribers) | Pro: $79/mo billed monthly (1,000 subscribers) |
| Price rises with list size | No | Yes | Yes |
| Free trial of paid plans | Not applicable | Page did not state a trial length | 14-day free trial, no credit card required |
Sources: Substack about and features pages, beehiiv pricing page, Kit pricing page, all as of November 20, 2026.
beehiiv's prices climb in buckets as your list grows. On its pricing page, Lite at up to 10,000 subscribers is $139 a month billed monthly, for example. Kit's page says paying yearly saves 17% on Pro, but it did not show an annual total, and it did not list an annual Creator price. When we checked, Kit's page also showed a promotion on the first three months of Creator. Promotions change, so check the current pricing page.
For deeper plan detail, our Kit pricing breakdown and Substack pricing guide go plan by plan.
What fees do they take on paid subscriptions and sales?
The headline cuts are 10% for Substack, 0% for beehiiv, and 3.5% plus $0.30 per sale for Kit, each with conditions.
| Fee | Substack | beehiiv | Kit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Platform cut on paid subscriptions | 10% revenue share | 0% ("not in trial") | 3.5% + $0.30 per USD transaction |
| Card processing | "Standard Stripe processing fees apply on top" | Stripe: 2.9% + $0.30 per transaction | Stripe is the only processor (fee listed above) |
| Plan needed to charge readers | None | Lite or higher | Any plan, including Free |
| Paid recommendations fee | Not stated | Not stated | 23.5% Kit fee |
Sources, as of November 20, 2026:
- Substack's about page says "Writers keep 90% of their revenue minus credit card fees." Its features page says it takes "a 10% revenue share only when a creator earns money through paid subscriptions."
- beehiiv's pricing page lists "0% Take Rate on Paid Subscriptions (not in trial)" on Lite. Its FAQ says "beehiiv takes 0% of your paid subscription revenue," and notes Stripe's standard fee of 2.9% + $0.30.
- Kit's help article Sell digital products with Kit says "Selling in USD costs 3.5% + $0.30 per transaction" and that Stripe is the only payment platform it supports. Its pricing page shows the same 3.5% + 30c on all plans.
One caution on Kit. Its pricing page also contains a line saying "Kit only takes 0.6% of the total fees," which the page does not explain. The help article and the pricing table both say 3.5% + $0.30, so confirm the fee in your own account before you set prices.
What does that look like on real numbers?
Here is an illustration using only the published fees above. It is arithmetic, not a forecast. Imagine 100 paid readers at $10 a month, so $1,000 a month and 100 transactions.
- Substack: 10% is $100, plus Stripe's processing fees. Substack's pages did not itemise the Stripe rate, so we leave that number out.
- beehiiv Lite, monthly billing: 0% platform cut. Stripe at 2.9% + $0.30 is $29 plus $30, so $59. Add the $59 plan fee if your list is under 1,000. Total about $118.
- Kit Free: 3.5% + $0.30 is $35 plus $30, so $65, with no plan fee if you stay on Free and under 10,000 subscribers. On Creator, add $39.
The order flips as revenue grows. A flat plan fee matters less when revenue is high, and a percentage matters more. Taxes, currency, refunds and app-store purchases change the numbers too. Substack's features page says it supports payments "via Stripe or IAP" (in-app purchase), which follow their own rules.
Who owns the list, and can you export it?
All three say you can take your subscriber list with you. That makes the first choice less permanent than it feels.
- Substack's features page says "Creators own their content and subscriber list" and that you can export your full publication data, including your complete subscriber list, at any time.
- beehiiv's pricing page lists data exports on every plan, including Free.
- Kit's help article on Creator Network reporting says the Subscribers page export is "a CSV file with information like the subscriber's email address, custom fields, and Tags."
Export is not the same as a painless move. Paid subscribers sit inside a payment processor, and readers may need to see a new sender in their inbox before they trust it. Before you migrate, read our Substack alternatives guide, which covers what to check when leaving.
Which platform has a discovery network for new newsletters?
Each has one, built differently, and none of the three publishes a figure we could verify for how many readers its network sends to a new newsletter.
| Discovery feature | Substack | beehiiv | Kit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Free recommendations | Cross-publication recommendations, leaderboards, explore page | Recommendation Network on all plans | Free Recommendations on all plans |
| Paid growth | Not described on the pages fetched | Paid recommendations on Lite and Pro | Paid Recommendations on Creator and Pro |
| Earn by recommending others | Not described on the pages fetched | Yes, on paid plans | Yes, Creator and Pro, with a 23.5% Kit fee |
Sources: Substack features page, beehiiv recommendations page, Kit pricing page, all as of November 20, 2026.
Substack calls its network "a built-in discovery network that no other newsletter platform offers." That is Substack's own claim. beehiiv's recommendations page says its old Boosts feature is "now called paid recommendations." Kit's pricing page uses the terms Free Recommendations and Paid Recommendations.
A discovery network brings readers who already read newsletters. It does not tell you whether your topic has demand. That is a separate question, covered below.
How do you pick? The Four-Route Creator Fit test
The Four-Route Creator Fit test sorts you by how you plan to earn, because fees and features only matter relative to that. Find the route that describes you, then check the one or two facts that decide it.
| Your route | Usually fits | The fact that decides it | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Free newsletter, growth first | Substack or beehiiv Free | Which discovery network your readers use | beehiiv Free caps at 2,500 subscribers |
| 2. Paid subscriptions as the main income | beehiiv paid plan or Substack | Your expected revenue versus a flat plan fee | Substack's 10% grows with revenue |
| 3. Selling products, courses or services | Kit | Automated sequences and per-sale fees | Kit Free has no visual automations or sequences |
| 4. Moving an existing audience | Whichever fits your route 1-3 | Export and import support on both ends | Paid subscriber migration and sender trust |
Route 1: You want a free newsletter that grows
Start on Substack or beehiiv Free if growth matters more than revenue right now. Substack costs nothing and has its own reader network. beehiiv Free includes its Recommendation Network but stops at 2,500 subscribers, and custom domains, referral programs and paid subscriptions start on Lite, per its pricing page. If you are unsure what to write about, our list of newsletter niches is a good starting point.
Route 2: Paid subscriptions are the business
Compare a percentage against a plan fee. Substack's 10% costs nothing at zero revenue and more as you grow. beehiiv's 0% take comes with a monthly plan that rises with list size, plus Stripe's fee. Kit sits between, with a per-sale fee on any plan. Run the arithmetic above with your own expected numbers. Our guide to paid newsletter niches covers which topics readers tend to pay for.
Route 3: You sell products, courses or services
Kit usually fits this route best, because selling through email depends on automated sequences. Kit's pricing page lists unlimited visual automations and automated email sequences on Creator and Pro, and none on Free. Its help article says digital products work on every plan. For a fuller look at Kit's strengths and gaps, read our Kit review, and compare Kit alternatives if the automation price is too high.
Route 4: You already have an audience on another platform
Check export on the old side and import on the new side before anything else. All three say you can export, as shown above. Kit publishes a help article on migrating from Substack to Kit. Then choose the destination using routes 1 to 3, since your earning model matters more than where you started.
What are the common mistakes when choosing a newsletter platform?
Most mistakes come from comparing features before deciding how you will earn.
- Comparing headline cuts only. A 0% take with a plan fee can cost more than 10% at low revenue, and less at high revenue.
- Using old ConvertKit prices. Kit's plans and names have changed, so use the current Kit page.
- Assuming a free plan can charge readers. beehiiv Free cannot. Substack and Kit can.
- Ignoring list-size pricing. beehiiv and Kit both price by subscriber bucket, so cost rises as you grow.
- Counting on a discovery network for demand. Recommendations spread a newsletter people want. They do not create the want.
- Skipping the export check. Confirm you can leave before you commit years of work.
- Trusting old comparison posts. Including ours. Re-check every fee on the official page on the day you decide.
How do you check a newsletter topic has demand first?
Check whether real people already ask for what you plan to write, before you pick a platform. Platform choice is reversible. A topic nobody wants is the expensive mistake.
- Write down the reader you want and the problem your newsletter solves for them.
- Search Reddit and forums for that problem in the reader's own words.
- Note repeated questions, complaints and requests that keep coming back.
- Check whether existing newsletters already answer them well.
- Draft three issue topics straight from those threads, then decide.
Our walkthrough on finding Substack topics from Reddit shows the method in detail, and how to grow your Substack covers what comes after launch. If you want a broader yes-or-no view of one platform, see is Substack worth it.
When is none of these the right choice?
None of the three fits well if you need a full membership site, a store with physical products, or a self-hosted publication you fully control. In those cases a website platform, a store builder, or a self-hosted tool may fit better. Our Substack vs Ghost comparison covers the self-hosted route. It is also fine to start with none of them: a simple list and a clear topic matter more than the tool.
Final Thoughts
The beehiiv vs Substack vs Kit choice gets easier once you know your route. Free growth points to Substack or beehiiv Free. Paid subscriptions mean doing fee arithmetic with your own numbers. Selling products points to Kit's automations. Moving an audience means checking export and import first. Whatever you pick, re-check the fees on each official page, because they change.
The step that saves the most time comes before the platform: making sure readers want your topic. If you are 18 or older and want to see what people actually ask about and complain about on Reddit before you choose a newsletter topic, start the 3-day free trial. A card is required, you get 1 scan a day during the trial, and it then costs $19 or $49 a month unless you cancel.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better, beehiiv, Substack or Kit?
None is better for everyone. Substack suits writers who want to start with no monthly cost and value its built-in discovery network. beehiiv suits operators who want 0% take on paid subscriptions and an ad network on paid plans. Kit suits creators who sell products and need automated email sequences. Match the platform to how you plan to earn.
Which newsletter platform takes the lowest cut of paid subscriptions?
On their own pages as of November 20, 2026, beehiiv states a 0% take rate on paid subscriptions, Kit lists 3.5% plus $0.30 per USD transaction, and Substack keeps 10% plus card fees. beehiiv still charges a monthly plan fee and Stripe processing, so the lowest cut is not always the lowest total cost.
Can I move my subscribers from Substack to beehiiv or Kit?
Yes. Substack says you can export your full publication data, including your complete subscriber list, at any time. beehiiv lists data exports on every plan, and Kit offers a CSV export from its Subscribers page. Kit also has a help article on migrating from Substack. Expect some open-rate drop while readers adjust to the new sender.
Is Kit the same as ConvertKit?
Yes. Kit's own homepage describes itself as Kit (formerly ConvertKit). Older guides, including some on this site, still use the ConvertKit name. Plan names and prices have changed since the rename, so check the current Kit pricing page rather than relying on older ConvertKit numbers.
Do I need a paid plan to run a paid newsletter?
It depends on the platform. Substack lets you turn on paid subscriptions without a monthly fee and takes 10% of revenue. Kit says paid newsletters and digital products are available on every plan, including Free. beehiiv lists paid subscriptions only on Lite and above, so its free plan cannot charge readers.
Not sure which niche actually has readers?
PainPointMap scans the communities your target readers already post in and shows you the questions they keep asking — so you pick a topic with proven demand instead of guessing.
See What Readers Are AskingCovers competitor analysis, SaaS go-to-market strategy, and how founders use community research to find product-market fit.